Lawmakers plot to curb independent regulators
WASHINGTON – Nobody likes to be regulated.
So a recent “bipartisan outreach” by lawmakers to industry associations not surprisingly found that regulations were poorly designed, unduly burdensome, and nowhere near worth all the trouble.
These were the main conclusions in a report put out earlier this month by the Republican majority staff of the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs.
The thousand-plus page report on 50 responses from “businesses, trade associations, consumer advocacy groups and environmental groups” somehow tilted in this Republican staff report very much in favor of industry’s point of view.
Committee chair Ron Johnson, a Wisconsin Republican, put the appropriate partisan spin on it: “In my view, the federal government’s current approach to regulations and rulemaking is one of the reasons why our economy continues to struggle six years after the Great Recession, and why so many of our fellow citizens remain out of work, underemployed, or struggling to make ends meet.”
Regulations are the favorite bogeyman of the business lobby and this conclusion represents no great news. Industry’s knee-jerk reaction to any new regulation is that it will have “unintended consequences” and the costs will far outweigh the benefits.
The overview of the report makes its bias clear.
The main “findings” are that environmental regulations are “a top concern of industry leaders,” that new workplace rules “will harm businesses due to increased compliance costs and additional burdens placed on employers,” that regulatory agencies “frequently underestimate the implementation costs and broader effects” of rules, that Dodd-Frank financial regulations have a “ripple effect” on business and need “streamlining.”
Alone among the findings highlighted is a single bullet point to the effect that “labor organizations, consumers and progressives” actually like many regulations because they protect health, public safety, the public and the environment. Their main complaint is that timelines for implementation are often too generous.
This hardly does justice to the extensive comments defending regulations and criticizing corporate malfeasance from respondents such as the AFL-CIO, Center for Progressive Reform, Coalition for Sensible Safeguards, Consumer Federation of America, Consumers Union, Environmental Defense Fund, and Public Citizen.
The new report is clearly intended as an alibi for Republicans – abetted by some business-friendly “centrist” Democrats – to infringe on the freedom of theoretically independent regulatory agencies to formulate and enforce rules that protect workers, consumers, investors and financial services customers.
The New York Times reported last week that efforts are underfoot to put together proposals for “regulatory accountability” that would tie these agencies in knots. These would include a requirement to submit any “economically significant” rule proposal to the Congressional Budget Office to vet on the basis of its own cost-benefit analysis.
Not only would such a requirement add months to the already lengthy process of getting a rule proposal finalized, it would represent a major breach in the effort to shield these independent agencies from partisan meddling.
Along with Johnson, Republican Senators working on the package reportedly are Rob Portman of Ohio, Susan Collins of Maine, James Lankford of Oklahoma, and Roy Blunt of Missouri.
Among Democrats supporting the effort is Sen. Mark Warner of Virginia, who worked on the predecessor bills to the new legislative package.
Warner made a fortune in the private sector using the knowledge of telecommunications law gleaned as a Senate staffer and is one of the richest members of Congress, with a net worth estimated at more than $200 million.
Others involved are Heidi Heitkamp of North Dakota and Joe Manchin of West Virginia – right-leaning Democrats from red states – and Angus King, an independent from Maine who caucuses with the Democrats.
These lawmakers seized on President Barack Obama’s passing reference to “outdated regulations” in his State of the Union speech earlier this month as indicating support for their plans.
“I think there are outdated regulations that need to be changed,” Obama said to applause from both sides of the aisle. “There is red tape that needs to be cut.”
Even bank critic Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., says regulatory reform is needed. “But this package heads in the wrong direction,” she is quoted as saying in the Times, “giving lobbyists and lawyers more chances to block outcomes they don’t like.”
The current rulemaking process already gives industry and other stakeholders ample time to provide feedback, which agency staffers are obliged to meticulously analyze. Industry groups often inundate the agencies with form letters to gum up this comment period and extend it for several months.
But it does provide industry an opportunity to air their concerns about costs, unintended consequences, crippling burdens and all the other nefarious problems they have with regulations that may save the lives of workers and consumers and prevent fraud in financial transactions.
What the current process does not do is allow lawmakers and their minions to further obstruct or delay regulations, most of which they have mandated in legislation.
That would change if this bipartisan phalanx of lawmakers listens to the one-sided feedback from their corporate donors.
Columnist Darrell Delamaide — @ddelamaide on Twitter — has reported on business and economics from New York, Paris, Berlin and Washington for Dow Jones news service, Barron's, Institutional Investor and Bloomberg News service, among others.