Paying It Forward: How Donte Whitner and James Luthardt Are Fighting a Broken System—and Winning

Donte Whitner may have been joking when he warned, “Some of the things I say will provide a lot of shock value,” but his message is deadly serious. The former Pro Bowl safety and top 10 NFL draft pick is sounding an alarm—not for dramatic effect, but because he understands the uphill battle he and investment guru James Luthardt face in trying to change the investment landscape for professional athletes. “We’re taking a different approach. But we’re trying to accomplish the impossible.”  

Disrupting powerful institutions rarely earns applause. “You come into the league at 20 or 22. You’re not equipped to say no to people, you don’t understand finances or even basic consumerism, and suddenly you're surrounded by guys earning ten times your salary. You're competing on the field—and at the car dealership,” Whitner says. 

"What athletes need," Whitner argues, "is someone who’s been there. Someone who can translate complex information into something real—someone who’s walked in your cleats. Until you confront past trauma related to life and money and close the knowledge gap, you may never reach your full potential as a professional athlete. Off-field distractions, not to mention a lack of financial literacy, and missed opportunities to invest wisely can hold you back on the field and from building generational wealth. You have to build a pro-bowler mindset and that goes beyond having a financial advisor." 

Whitner may sound like a financial advisor, but he’s not—and he doesn’t want to be. Instead, he’s teamed up with his financial advisor and business partner, James Paul Luthardt, founder of Kirtland Hills Capital, to bridge the gap of financial and life literacy and long-term financial security and self-actualization. Together, they’re helping players avoid the same pitfalls that Whitner and so many of his peers experienced. 

“We’re in this for the long haul,” says Luthardt. “It doesn’t matter if someone made $100 million—if it’s gone a decade later, what did it really mean? Our goal is to help players build true financial literacy, secure that second or third contract, and ultimately create more wealth after their careers than they did on the field. That starts with Donte mentoring players and their families through the realities of sudden wealth and the unresolved traumas often hidden behind fame and fortune. He’s teaching them how to be Pro Bowlers in life—by building exposure and vision, bridging the gap between low-income backgrounds and high-net-worth environments, providing stable mentorship, access to education, and networks for success beyond sports. It’s about instilling self-belief, a purpose bigger than the game, even down to the discipline of watching film the right way and cultivating healthy relationships. These are the overlooked foundations of greatness.” 

Luthardt brings over 15 years of experience managing top family office assets for some of the wealthiest families in the country. Whitner brings over 15 years of lived experience inside the NFL machine. Their approach is unique—and deeply personal. “I’m exhausted from hearing about how much players make,” Luthardt says. “That’s being rich. I care about how much wealth they’re building and keeping long after their playing days. More notably, we want to create an unmatched ratio of eventual net worth compared to net earnings from their professional career.” 

The problem, as Luthardt sees it, is that too many athletes choose advisors based on brand name or popularity—not performance and investment talent. “The current published advisor rankings are sales trophies. They reflect how good someone is at gathering assets, not managing them—they are very misleading and confusing for players.” 

Luthardt’s solution? Assemble a team of “Pro Bowlers” in investing. Elite professionals in real estate, venture capital, private equity, debt markets, and more. Each one is an investment specialist. Luthardt operates with the same mandates as a family office model that prioritizes client value and independence—but not a one-stop shop model that many brokers or multi-family offices sell. Rather than charging layers of fees or promoting proprietary funds, he connects clients to top-tier specialists directly and removes conflicts of interest and middlemen, cutting clients’ costs significantly. 

Whitner calls himself a “Pro Bowler at life,” and his story backs that up. Raised in poverty by a single mother, with a father in prison, he became one of the league’s highest-paid safeties. “I had to figure life out early,” he says. “If you didn’t, you ended up on the other end of the spectrum—and trust me, you didn’t want to end up there.” 

At 16, he enrolled at Ohio State. At 20, he was a top-10 pick in the NFL Draft. Now, he’s channeling hard-earned life lessons into mentorship. “I’m not some athlete mascot for a financial institution trying to use me for sales,” he says. “I had advisors like that. My life experiences are unique, and that brings real value to athletes—it’s about relatability. I don’t want to be an advisor. I want to be a translator of life. Finances are just one part of building a great life and reaching your full potential to self-actualize in this life. I’m a conduit—between James, his network, and the next generation of athletes.” 

He adds: “When I see predators coming for the players—people taking and giving nothing in return—it hits me. That’s when Donte HITNER comes out. I attack life the same way I played football: head-on.” 

And while agents can secure record-setting contracts, Whitner says they often stop short. “They can make a guy rich, but they can’t make him wealthy. That’s what we’re trying to change. It’s about converting earned income into passive income—owning assets, businesses, real estate. That’s wealth.” 

For Luthardt, the ultimate value isn’t just numbers on a statement—it’s transformation. “The goal is to create a strategy to replace earned income and scale their net worth beyond what they ever thought possible—we want their lifestyle to grow, not be reduced in retirement.” 

Whitner believes the knowledge is already available—just not shared with players correctly. So, Whitner and Luthardt built their own team of top entrepreneurs, top family offices, and top-tier investors to share that knowledge. “You need Pro Bowlers in wealth just like in football,” Whitner says. “Elite attorneys, CPAs, investors and operators. We’re not just picking one advisor or firm—we’re building a team with no weak links and seeing the dozens of professional athletes in our “tribe” winning and building generational wealth feels as good as when I won my first pro-bowl.” 

As for Whitner’s post-retirement plans? A beach vacation was never in the cards. “I have a deep love for my professional athlete’s fraternity,” he says. “We sacrificed everything to get here. So, when I see guys getting taken advantage of, I feel it. I lived it. And that’s why I’m willing to do the hard thing, say the hard truths. To date, James and I have had the privilege of guiding approximately 100 professional athletes on their path to building generational wealth—something we take great pride in. We’re trying to accomplish the impossible—but my whole life has been about doing exactly that.”

  The information provided in this article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers should not rely solely on the content of this article and are encouraged to seek professional advice tailored to their specific circumstances. We disclaim any liability for any loss or damage arising directly or indirectly from the use of, or reliance on, the information presented.