Yahoo now an Alibaba tracking stock, and IRS ruling is key
SAN FRANCISCO — Three years ago, I advised technology investors to buy Yahoo shares on the news that it had hired Marissa Mayer away from rival Google to become CEO.
Her long and successful track record as a product manager for the No. 1 Internet search company and her youthful energy would inject the company with enthusiasm that stock buyers would respond to, I argued.
Since that time, Yahoo YHOO shares have risen 150%, roughly doubling the 75% gain of the Nasdaq Composite Index over the same time.
The reason for the attractive stock performance, however, had less to do with Mayer's actions than with the lucrative investment in Alibaba made by her predecessor as CEO, Yahoo co-founder Jerry Yang.

Those investment gains have now been fully priced into Yahoo shares.
So much so that the company bowed to investor pressure to spin out its Alibaba stake into a separate stock.
Moreover, the equity gains from Alibaba BABA that helped propel Yahoo shares higher are expected to plunge this year.
They already have.
For the quarter ended in March, those gains dropped by roughly two-thirds to $100 million, from $301 million a year earlier.
For all of 2015, Yahoo's gain on equity investments is expected to plummet more than 60%, to $396 million, from $1 billion last year, according to a report Wednesday from stock analyst Martin Pyykkonen of Rosenblatt Securities, a buy-side research firm.
The reason?
Alibaba's profit margins, both for operating income and net income, have been getting squeezed amid heavy investment.
More Alibaba insiders are also now free to sell their pre-IPO shares, helping to push down that stock by more than a third since it hit a high of $120 last fall.
Pyykkonen's report also shows the eroding financial health of Yahoo's business operations excluding its stakes in Alibaba and Yahoo Japan.
After seeing operating income plunge 78% last year, to $143 million, as Mayer spent aggressively on new markets, Yahoo is expected to swing to an operating loss for all of 2015.
The company posted an operating loss of $88 million in the first quarter, and Pyykkonen expects its operations to lose about $118 million this year.
For the quarter ended in June, he expects Yahoo to swing to an operating loss of $58.6 million, compared to $38.4 million in operating income for the same period last year.
Yahoo will report results after the markets close July 21.
If its top line is in line with Wall Street expectations, it will mark the 10th straight quarter that revenue (minus the company's traffic acquisition costs, or TAC) has stagnated in a range between $1 billion and $1.2 billion.
That non-growth revenue trajectory, along with the company's operating losses, is not a viable, long-term business model.
That helps explain why Yahoo shares are down 24% this year, lagging an 8% gain for the Nasdaq.
Alibaba shares are down roughly the same amount year-to-date, and since the beginning of June, the two stocks have been trading in lock-step.
With its top line stagnant and its operations losing money, Yahoo has become a de facto tracking stock for Alibaba — even before it spins off its stake.
Yahoo investors are so focused on Alibaba that a statement in May from an Internal Revenue Service official, who cast doubt on Yahoo's plans for a tax-free spinoff, sent its shares down 7% in one day.

And no wonder: The difference between a tax-free transaction and one that is taxed could be a whopping $12 billion, according to Pyykkonen.
If the IRS does rain on Yahoo's tax-free plans, the stock is going to tank.
Even if not, given the state of its core businesses,Yahoo's stock could be sold off dramatically after it completes the Alibaba spinoff.
Conversely, the only things likely to drive its shares higher this year are a better-than-expected quarterly report, an acquisition big enough to move overall revenue higher or a surge in Alibaba shares.
Without any of those catalysts, the near-term outlook for Yahoo shares remains weak.
John Shinal has covered tech and financial markets for more than 15 years at Bloomberg, BusinessWeek,The San Francisco Chronicle, Dow Jones MarketWatch, Wall Street Journal Digital Network and others. Follow him on Twitter: @johnshinal .