soft-shell crab exportersoftshell crab exporterVietnam crab exporterVietnamese mud crab export
Apple at 50 🍎 AWS turns 20 🥳 Want the lowest ping? 🎮 Get shopping texts 🛍️
TECH
VMware

VMware selling drives down value of Dell’s mammoth EMC bid

John Shinal
Special for USA TODAY
Oct. 13, 2015Updated Oct. 14, 2015, 9:59 a.m. ET

SAN FRANCISCO — One group of tech investors has already provided their unvarnished opinion of a plan by hardware-maker Dell to acquire EMC, the No. 1 maker of storage hardware and software, for $67 billion.

That plan involves mostly cash, but more than a quarter of its financial consideration is derived from the creation of a tracking stock for VMware, a storage-software company in which EMC owns an 81% stake.

If the selling by VMWare shareholders since reports of the deal surfaced is any indicator, they’re giving it an emphatic thumbs-down.

VMware shares closed at $82.09 on Oct. 7, before reports surfaced later that day that EMC and Dell were in talks for a deal.

Yet the issuance of a large amount of new stock pegged to VMware shares will create serious dilution for its existing shareholders, and they've noticed.

The stock has been sold off by 15% since last Wednesday.

The shares closed Tuesday at just under $70 a share, giving VMware a market value of $29.3 billion — $5 billion less than its valuation last week.

If VMware is now worth 15% less than when the deal was struck, so is EMC, which as noted above owns four-fifths of the company.

EMC shares closed Tuesday at $27.59 a share, valuing the tech giant at $53 billion, or significantly less than the deal’s stated value.

Given the cash portion of the Dell offer is for $24.05 a share, its current share price means the stock market is valuing the financial consideration derived from a future VMware tracking stock to be no more than $3.54 a share.

That’s a far cry from the $9.10 a share stated by the companies.

If VMware shares keep falling, it’s a signal that investors think the deal will fall through or that its terms don’t properly value either EMC, VMware or both.

And keep falling they can, as there’s no so-called collar on the deal that could protect shareholders on the downside.

That means any future tracking stock pegged to the value of VMware shares will also be worth less than when the deal was signed.

“There’s no collar on the deal,” EMC CEO Joe Tucci said on a conference call with analysts on Monday.

The deal does have a "go-shop clause," Tucci said, which will allow EMC to solicit other offers.

The drop in EMC shares on Tuesday can be explained by fundamental reasons, as the company on Monday also pre-announced third-quarter results which were slightly less than Wall Street estimates.

But given VMware’s pre-announced results topped expectations, its stock price decline looks to be the result of arbitrage selling pressure created by the Dell-EMC deal.

John Shinal, technology columnist for USA Today.

The drop in VMware shares caused concern from at least one hardware analyst on the conference call that EMC and VMWare held to discuss the deal on Monday.

Toni Sacconaghi of Sanford Bernstein noted that the deal was already worth less than the stated $67.1 billion, given the drop in VMware shares.

In response, EMC’s Tucci said of Dell's founder that “Michael (Dell) intends to be a bigger owner of VMware over time.”
Minutes earlier on the same call, VMware CEO Patrick Gelsinger said essentially the same thing.

“It is Michael’s intention to be a larger, longer-term owner of VMware over time. He intends to repurchase more economic interest in the company,” Gelsinger said.

That may be so, but until the deal is finalized next year, it is very much in Michael Dell’s financial interest to see the value of VMware decline.

That would, after all, reduce the total financial consideration his company will have to pay to acquire EMC.

Retail investors may therefore want to wait until they see evidence, such as a securities filing, that Michael Dell is indeed a buyer of VMware before they consider the same move.

Until that comes, investors with a short-term time horizon should sell their VMware shares, while those experienced in arbitrage may find this a good opportunity to sell them short.

Based on stock trading since the deal became known, it doesn’t look like Dell will be paying $67 billion for EMC.

Follow USA TODAY tech columnist John Shinal on Twitter: @johnshinal.

Featured Weekly Ad